A federal judge in Maine ruled Friday that the Hermon School Department violated the First Amendment and Maine’s public accommodations law when its School Committee refused The Pines Church a year-long lease to hold Sunday services at Hermon High School.
Chief U.S. District Judge Lance E. Walker issued the 37-page decision on Nov. 13 after a two-day bench trial. He found that at least three of the committee’s five voting members acted under “bad motive.” He awarded the church and its lead pastor, Matt Gioia, $1 in nominal damages and reasonable costs, said they may claim attorney’s fees, and denied their request for an injunction.
What the ruling says
The church started in Gioia’s home and later rented an Orono movie theater month to month. In 2022, Gioia asked to rent high school space for a few hours on Sunday mornings. The Girl Scouts, Boy Scouts, youth basketball and Hermon Recreation already used the school under the district’s community-use policy.
Before the vote, committee member Christopher McLaughlin sent questions through then-Superintendent Micah Grant about the church’s views on same-sex marriage, abortion access, gender-affirming medical care, conversion therapy and sex education. It was the first long-term lease request the committee had considered, and no other prospective tenant had been asked such questions.
At the committee’s December 2022 meeting, a motion for a six-month lease died for lack of a second. The committee then voted 4-1 to offer only a month-to-month arrangement, with McLaughlin the lone no vote. Gioia turned it down.
Walker found that McLaughlin, Stephanie Oiler and Vice Chair Karen Shorey acted under bad motive. He found the members’ practical concerns about cleaning, parking and space “threadbare” and called the month-to-month proposal “an offer designed to be rejected.”
Why it matters
The Supreme Court held in Good News Club v. Milford Central School in 2001 that a public school that opens its doors to the community cannot shut out a group for being religious. Walker applied that rule here, writing that “novelty is not a basis to discriminate against religious organizations.” Before the vote, a Dec. 6, 2022, memo from the district’s own lawyers told the committee to judge the church by the same criteria it would apply to any non-religious group.
Daily Beltway analysis: the $1 award is symbolic, but the finding is not. A federal court has now said in writing that quizzing a church about abortion and gender policy before deciding whether to rent it a school auditorium is evidence of bias. The district also faces the church’s legal fees.
“This ruling affirms a fundamental principle: when public schools open their facilities to community groups such as sports teams, scouts, and recreation programs, they cannot exclude churches simply because of their faith,” said Bob Tyler, president of Advocates for Faith & Freedom, which represented the church.
The school department’s response
Superintendent Barbara Sargent told Fox News Digital the department was reviewing the decision. “While this legal matter has concluded, the Hermon School department’s dedication to its students remains unchanged,” she said.
The ruling also records that Oiler, when she moved for the month-to-month lease, was careful to emphasize that her concerns had nothing to do with the organization. Walker did not find the district’s written rental policy unconstitutional and declined to order a lease. He credited Grant, writing that his conduct “supported and favored treating the Church equally to all other potential public users of public space.”
What’s next
Under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 4, a notice of appeal is due within 30 days after entry of the judgment. If no timely appeal is filed, the District of Maine’s Local Rule 54.2 gives the church 30 days after that appeal window closes to file its claim for attorneys’ fees.


