DOJ tells appeals court its Alaska Senate suit is moot

The Justice Department has asked a federal appeals court to declare its Alaska Senate lawsuit moot, conceding there is no longer any way to sort out ballots cast for a second candidate named Dan Sullivan. Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in this month’s election.

The Nov. 19 brief, signed by Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr., asks the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to vacate U.S. District Judge Sharon L. Gleason’s Nov. 1 dismissal and send the case back to be dismissed as moot. It also opposes a request for sanctions against government lawyers.

What the filing says

The suit sought to bar Alaska from certifying any result that could have been changed by voter confusion, pending an investigation of whether votes for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant for the senator. The government also wanted potentially affected ballots preserved and segregated before Election Day.

Gleason denied that request. Ballots were mixed together in the ballot box on Election Day and carry nothing identifying who cast which votes, so the United States now “reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means” of determining whether those votes were meant for the senator.

The government still defends the case itself. The brief calls Gleason’s standing ruling wrong and frames the suit as an effort to let voters cast ballots that reflected their true choice despite confusion it blames on Daniel J. Sullivan’s campaign, which it says Peltola’s campaign encouraged.

Why it matters

Daily Beltway analysis: the filing ends the last federal court fight over Peltola’s win, the ninth Democratic Senate pickup for the next Congress. Seeking vacatur, rather than simply dropping the appeal, would erase Gleason’s standing ruling instead of leaving it on the books as precedent against the government in future election cases.

The case grew out of a candidacy Alaska’s own election officials tried to block. On June 15, the Division of Elections rejected Daniel J. Sullivan’s filing, finding it was meant to confuse or mislead voters rather than declare a good-faith candidacy. State courts, including the Alaska Supreme Court on June 29, put him back on the ballot. Peltola took 50.1% of first-choice votes in preliminary results.

The civil case is effectively over, but the criminal inquiry is not. The Alaska Bureau of Investigation is still investigating allegations tied to the race, the state Department of Public Safety confirmed Wednesday. Peltola’s campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and Dan J. Sullivan have denied any involvement in the alleged recruitment effort.

The other side

The League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause, represented by the ACLU, had asked the 9th Circuit to summarily affirm Gleason and weigh sanctions. Their Nov. 9 motion called the government’s legal theory indefensible and asked the court to make its lawyers explain why they should not be sanctioned for a frivolous appeal. The department answered that the sanctions request was “overheated” and that its appeal of the standing decision is not frivolous.

What’s next

Alaska’s Division of Elections plans to certify results, including the Senate race, on Nov. 25. The 9th Circuit has not ruled on the dueling motions. Under the court’s original schedule, the government’s opening brief is due Dec. 14.

Sources

Daily Beltway
Thomashttps://dailybeltway.com
Thomas is the editor of Daily Beltway, covering Congress, the White House and national politics. Daily Beltway's coverage is compiled from official releases, documents, on-record statements and other news reports, and every story is reviewed before publishing. Corrections: see our Editorial Standards page.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Read

The Daily Beltway Briefing

How we handle your email