Full 3rd Circuit won't rehear McIver bid to toss ICE assault charges

The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Thursday refused to rehear Rep. LaMonica McIver’s bid to throw out the federal charges stemming from her May 2025 confrontation with immigration officers at Delaney Hall in Newark. The one-paragraph order, dated Nov. 19 and signed by Circuit Judge Cindy K. Chung, denied rehearing both by the original panel and by the court en banc.

Three judges, Restrepo, Krause and Montgomery-Reeves, voted to grant the petition. The denial leaves in place an August panel ruling that the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause does not shield the New Jersey Democrat from the two counts that accuse her of physically striking officers, moving the case a step closer to trial.

What the court’s rulings do

McIver is charged in a three-count indictment under 18 U.S.C. § 111(a) with forcibly assaulting, resisting, impeding or interfering with federal officers. Count One alleges she drove her forearm into one officer and grabbed him to try to restrain him. Count Two alleges she pushed past a second officer, striking that officer with both forearms as she went back into the secured area of the facility.

In its Aug. 26 opinion, a panel of Circuit Judges Bibas, Chung and Ambro affirmed the district court’s refusal to dismiss Counts One and Two. Writing for the majority, Chung concluded that pushing past and forcibly striking someone is plainly non-legislative conduct because it is not integral to the legislative process. The panel sent Count Three, which covers a broader range of conduct, back to the district court to decide whether it reaches protected legislative acts. It also held that separation-of-powers principles give lawmakers no immunity beyond the Speech or Debate Clause, and it dismissed, for lack of jurisdiction, the part of her appeal challenging the rejection of her selective and vindictive prosecution claims.

The rehearing order states that no judge who concurred in the decision asked for rehearing and that a majority of active judges did not vote for it. Judge Ambro’s vote was limited to panel rehearing.

Why it matters

Daily Beltway analysis: the ruling draws a clear line. An oversight visit to an ICE facility is protected legislative work, but physically striking federal officers is not, and the full court has now let that holding stand. Lawmakers get no special pass from the assault laws that apply to everyone else.

Ambro, who dissented in part in August, agreed that members of Congress are not above the law but argued Count Two needed more fact-finding and that McIver should get discovery on her claim of political retaliation. The district court denied her motions to dismiss in January 2026, according to McIver’s office.

McIver’s response

McIver called the decision “disappointing” in a statement Thursday. “Because of a weaponized Department of Justice and because I dared to do my job and conduct oversight of ICE, I am facing 17 years in prison,” she said. “This result is frustrating, but my lawyers and I are looking at every possible option for what comes next.”

Rep. Rob Menendez also backed her on X.

What’s next

No new trial date has been announced. Under Supreme Court Rule 13, a petition asking the justices to take up the case would be due within 90 days of the Nov. 19 rehearing denial, or by Feb. 17, 2027.

Sources

If an embedded post does not load, these links open the originals.

Daily Beltway
Thomashttps://dailybeltway.com
Thomas is the editor of Daily Beltway, covering Congress, the White House and national politics. Daily Beltway's coverage is compiled from official releases, documents, on-record statements and other news reports, and every story is reviewed before publishing. Corrections: see our Editorial Standards page.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Read

The Daily Beltway Briefing

How we handle your email