Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has asked a Fort Bend County district court to strike down Houston Mayor John Whitmire’s executive order limiting when city police may contact U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The state filed a motion for summary judgment on Friday, Nov. 13, in a lawsuit it first brought against the city in April.
The motion asks the court to declare Executive Order 1-74 and the police circular that carries it out illegal under Senate Bill 4, the 2017 state law that bars cities from limiting cooperation with federal immigration enforcement, and to block them permanently. The fight now turns on a calendar: Paxton leaves office in January.
What the state’s motion asks for
Whitmire signed the order on Nov. 6. It tells Houston police to contact ICE about a person only when that person is already being jailed on new charges or other warrants. A driver who gets a traffic citation and an ICE administrative warrant hit is released without a call to the agency. Administrative warrants are civil documents issued by immigration officials, not criminal warrants signed by a judge.
The state argues that the order violates Section 752.053 of the Texas Government Code. That section bars a local entity from prohibiting or materially limiting a peace officer from assisting or cooperating with a federal immigration officer, including by providing enforcement help. According to Univision Houston, the filing says the order is not a neutral use of police resources because it targets one federal agency, and it asks for an injunction covering the city, the mayor, Police Chief J. Noe Diaz and all 16 council members.
“A municipality may not undermine or subvert local law enforcement cooperation and communication with federal immigration enforcement, whether by decree or by legislation,” the state wrote in the filing, as quoted by Houston Public Media.
Why it matters
This is Houston’s second attempt this year to pull its police back from ICE. On April 8, the City Council passed a Proposition A ordinance on a 12-5 vote that barred officers from detaining people on ICE administrative warrants during field encounters. The state sued on April 16. After Gov. Greg Abbott threatened more than $110 million in public safety funding, the council rewrote the ordinance, and police were again told to contact ICE about administrative warrants.
The cooperation was not theoretical. From April through September, Houston officers contacted ICE nearly 200 times and handed at least 36 people directly to the agency.
Daily Beltway analysis: The order came days after Democrats won Texas’s open statewide offices, and the city’s lawyers are betting the case outlasts the man who filed it. If the next attorney general drops SB 4 enforcement, a state law passed to stop sanctuary policies would stay on the books with no one in Austin willing to use it against Houston.
Houston’s response
City Attorney Arturo Michel signaled the city may simply wait. “It will be difficult for the Attorney General to obtain a court ruling before the new administration takes over, which has indicated it will not pursue SB4 enforcement of this nature,” Michel said in an email.
Some council members want the city to go further. “Ken Paxton is yet again trying to bully Houston into abandoning protections for our immigrant neighbors and families,” Council Member Alejandra Salinas said, urging the administration to fight the suit. Michel told council members in a Tuesday memo that their proposal to write the order into a city ordinance is unlawful, and Whitmire has opposed that effort.
What’s next
The court has not ruled on the motion, and no hearing date has been made public. Paxton’s term ends in January, when Democrat Nathan Johnson takes over as attorney general. Johnson’s campaign did not immediately respond to a question about whether he would let Houston implement the policy.


