Senate confirms Anna St. John to 5th Circuit on party-line vote

The Senate on Tuesday confirmed U.S. District Judge Anna St. John of Louisiana to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, voting 52-46 along party lines. Both Louisiana senators backed her, Democrats who voted opposed her, and Sens. Chris Murphy of Connecticut and Jim Risch of Idaho did not vote.

St. John fills the New Orleans seat held by Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt, who is retiring. The vote came one day after the Senate confirmed Daniel Desmond Domenico to the Tenth Circuit, 51-46, as Senate Republicans race to fill judicial vacancies before Democrats take the majority in January.

What the vote does

The roll call, vote No. 265 of the session, gives President Trump another lifetime appointment on the Fifth Circuit, the 17-seat appeals court that hears cases from federal trial courts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas. Republican Sens. Bill Cassidy and John Kennedy of Louisiana voted to confirm her.

The Senate received the nomination on July 14. On Nov. 12, senators voted to end debate and agreed by unanimous consent to hold the final vote no earlier than Monday, Nov. 16.

St. John has been on the federal trial bench in New Orleans only since April 23, according to The Times-Picayune | The Advocate. The paper reported that the Gulfport, Mississippi, native clerked for Fifth Circuit Judge Rhesa H. Barksdale and later served as general counsel of the Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, where she fought what she has called unfair class action settlements.

Why it matters

Fifth Circuit decisions go next to the Supreme Court, so the court often has the last word short of the justices on cases from three large states. Law.com reported that St. John is Trump’s 12th appeals court appointee of his second term and his first to the Fifth Circuit.

Daily Beltway analysis: the clock is the story. Democrats will take control of the Senate in January, and Republicans are using the lame-duck weeks to confirm as many judges as they can. Elevating a sitting district judge also moves faster, since much of the vetting was already done for her trial-court post. That’s our read: every appellate seat filled now is one Democrats will not get to shape next year.

The other side

Senate Democratic Whip Dick Durbin of Illinois, the top Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, accused Republicans on Tuesday of breaking committee norms to speed nominees through. “Republicans are in a mad scramble to confirm as many judicial nominees as possible before the Democrats take majority control of the Senate in January,” Durbin said at a committee business meeting.

“Senate Republicans turned obstruction of judicial nominees into an art form under President Obama,” he added. “So, forgive me if I shed no tears when Republicans complain about Democrats refusing to rubberstamp unqualified MAGA nominees once we take the majority in January.”

What’s next

The Judiciary Committee holds another nominations hearing on Wednesday, Nov. 18, according to Durbin’s office. Democrats take control of the Senate when the new Congress convenes in January; Durbin’s office noted new senators arrive on Jan. 3.

Sources

If an embedded post does not load, these links open the originals.

Daily Beltway
Thomashttps://dailybeltway.com
Thomas is the editor of Daily Beltway, covering Congress, the White House and national politics. Daily Beltway's coverage is compiled from official releases, documents, on-record statements and other news reports, and every story is reviewed before publishing. Corrections: see our Editorial Standards page.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Read

The Daily Beltway Briefing

How we handle your email